There is something fundamentally wrong with being a Calgary Flames fan when you find yourself disappointed after a win.
Not because the team played poorly. Not because the officiating was terrible. Not even because we somehow managed to surrender a two-goal lead in the third period.
No, the disappointment comes from the realization that another two points might move us further away from the kind of player who could change this franchise for the next decade.
It’s a ridiculous position to be in. We’re fans. We’re supposed to celebrate goals, cheer for victories, and believe that every winning streak is the beginning of something special.
But we’ve been here before.
The Calgary Flames have become remarkably good at being good enough. Good enough to compete. Good enough to give us hope. Occasionally good enough to win a division.
Just never quite good enough to finish the job.
And perhaps the most remarkable statistic in franchise history explains why.
Fourth Place Is Apparently Our First Place
Since moving to Calgary in 1980, the Flames have never selected a player higher than fourth overall.
Not once.
Sam Bennett, selected fourth in 2014, remains the highest draft pick of the Calgary era.
Meanwhile, the Pittsburgh Penguins built championships around Sidney Crosby, Evgeni Malkin and Marc-André Fleury. Chicago landed Patrick Kane and Jonathan Toews. Colorado drafted Nathan MacKinnon first overall, Gabriel Landeskog second and Cale Makar fourth.
Those organizations didn’t win championships simply because they drafted high. They developed their talent, surrounded it with the right players, and built teams capable of winning when it mattered.
But having access to extraordinary talent certainly didn’t hurt.
Calgary, on the other hand, has spent much of its existence occupying that uncomfortable space between legitimate contender and legitimate disaster.
Too good to secure a franchise-altering selection. Too inconsistent to make a serious championship run.
We’ve perfected the art of standing still while appearing to move forward.
Or have we?
The Rebuild That Forgot to Finish
Remember 2013?
Jarome Iginla was traded. Miikka Kiprusoff’s career was ending. The era that had given us the unforgettable 2004 Stanley Cup run was finally over.
It was time to rebuild.
And, for a little while, we actually did.
Sean Monahan arrived. Johnny Gaudreau emerged. Bennett was drafted. Matthew Tkachuk followed a couple of years later.
Suddenly, the Flames were exciting again.
In 2014–15, just two seasons after Iginla’s departure, Calgary made the playoffs and eliminated Vancouver in the first round. It was fantastic. Young players were contributing, the Saddledome was rocking, and the future looked bright.
We weren’t supposed to be this good this quickly.
By 2018–19, the Flames had finished first in the Western Conference with 107 points. Five games into the playoffs, Colorado sent them home.
In 2021–22, Calgary won the Pacific Division with 111 points. We had Gaudreau, Tkachuk, Elias Lindholm, an exceptional season from Jacob Markstrom, and a team that genuinely looked capable of making a run.
Then Edmonton eliminated us in five games.
Twice we had teams that looked like contenders. Twice the postseason reminded us that regular-season success and playoff success are very different things.
Then Gaudreau left, Tkachuk was traded, and the cycle started again.
But here’s the thing.
Those were fun teams to watch.
And sometimes I wonder whether we’ve become so focused on what they failed to accomplish that we’ve forgotten how much we enjoyed watching them try.
Four First-Overall Picks and Nothing to Show for It?
Of course, if we’re going to discuss the benefits of being terrible, we really should consult the experts.
Hello, Edmonton.
Between 2010 and 2015, the Oilers selected first overall four times.
Taylor Hall. Ryan Nugent-Hopkins. Nail Yakupov. Connor McDavid.
Four opportunities to select the best young player available in six years.
Calgary has never had one.
And yet, despite all that draft lottery success, the Oilers are still waiting for their first Stanley Cup since 1990.
To be fair, Edmonton has reached two consecutive Stanley Cup Finals. That is considerably closer than Calgary has come in a very long time.
But there’s a particularly beautiful piece of hockey irony buried in those defeats.
The Florida Panthers beat Edmonton for the Stanley Cup in both 2024 and 2025.
And who helped them do it?
Matthew Tkachuk and Sam Bennett.
Two of the highest-drafted players in Calgary Flames history, winning championships together with somebody else.
Bennett even took home the Conn Smythe Trophy in 2025.
Apparently, we knew how to draft some of the right pieces. We just couldn’t figure out how to finish the puzzle.
Edmonton’s history proves that being terrible doesn’t automatically make you great.
And if Edmonton isn’t the ideal consultant for rebuilding, perhaps Vancouver can offer some advice.
The Canucks have never used a first-overall pick either, despite decades of trying to escape their own cycles of frustration. They’ve reached three Stanley Cup Finals without winning one.
Perhaps the three Western Canadian franchises should establish a support group.
We could meet every spring. Most years, at least two of us would have plenty of free time.
Then a Goalie Got Hot, and Hockey Became Fun Again
Coming into this season, nobody was expecting the Flames to set the league on fire.
We knew this was a young team. We knew there would be growing pains. We knew we were probably going to lose a lot of games.
And then we lost our first five.
For anyone dreaming of a first-overall draft pick, the season was off to a wonderful start.
For those of us who actually enjoy watching hockey? Not so much.
Then Devin Cooley happened.
A couple of outstanding performances turned into a four-game winning streak. A team that looked lost suddenly started competing. Young players were finding confidence, goals were being scored, and the Flames were actually entertaining again.
Cooley wasn’t the only reason. The team tightened up defensively, the offence started contributing, and the players began feeding off each other’s energy.
But sometimes all a young team needs is somebody to show them that winning is possible.
Suddenly, we weren’t watching a team waiting for the season to end.
We were watching kids having fun playing hockey.
And that enthusiasm is contagious.
Nobody told Matvei Gridin that winning might hurt our draft position. Nobody told Zayne Parekh to save his best hockey for next season.
They’re competing because that’s what hockey players do.
And I’m finding myself enjoying it.
Which brings us to an uncomfortable question.
Are we really supposed to cheer against that?
Remember When a Goalie Changed Everything?
There’s something familiar about a relatively unknown goaltender arriving and changing the fortunes of a Calgary Flames team.
In November 2003, Calgary acquired Miikka Kiprusoff from San Jose.
Nobody was talking about a generational first-overall selection. Nobody was planning a decade-long rebuild.
The Flames needed a goalie.
They found one.
And what happened next became one of the greatest chapters in franchise history.
The 2004 Stanley Cup run was a perfect storm.
Kiprusoff was extraordinary. Jarome Iginla was a superstar. Martin Gelinas seemed to have a gift for scoring when it mattered most. A hardworking roster bought into Darryl Sutter’s system and refused to accept that it wasn’t supposed to be there.
Was Kiprusoff’s arrival a fluke?
Maybe the circumstances were. The talent certainly wasn’t.
But nobody could have predicted how perfectly everything would come together.
And that’s what makes hockey so wonderful.
Sometimes the best teams on paper don’t win.
Sometimes the favourites go home early.
And sometimes a team that nobody believes in comes within a single victory of winning the Stanley Cup.
You can’t draft that feeling first overall.
So What Do We Actually Want?
This is where I find myself questioning the entire obsession with tanking.
As fans, what exactly are we hoping for?
Do we want to spend several miserable seasons watching our team lose, hoping the lottery balls finally fall our way?
Do we want the elusive first-overall pick? The once-in-a-generation superstar who is supposedly going to change everything?
Of course we do.
Who wouldn’t want a Connor McDavid or Sidney Crosby wearing the Flaming C?
But what are we prepared to sacrifice for that chance?
And what happens if we finish last and don’t win the lottery? What happens if our first-overall pick turns out to be Nail Yakupov instead of Connor McDavid?
There are no guarantees.
And frankly, I’m not convinced I want to spend years cheering for failure just because it might eventually lead to success.
I want to be entertained.
I want to watch young players develop. I want to see the excitement when someone scores their first NHL goal. I want to see a goaltender steal a game we had absolutely no business winning.
I want to watch a team that loves playing hockey.
That doesn’t mean abandoning the rebuild.
Craig Conroy can keep developing prospects, accumulating young talent, and making decisions with the future in mind.
We don’t need to mortgage tomorrow to chase eighth place today.
But we shouldn’t be disappointed when those young players win, either.
If we finish near the bottom while building something special, so be it.
If those kids surprise everyone and push for the playoffs, even better.
Because maybe building a winning culture is just as important as winning the draft lottery.
Maybe Being Good Enough Isn’t a Curse
I’ve spent years wondering whether the Flames are destined to remain trapped in the middle.
Never the best. Never the worst. Always just close enough to make us believe.
But watching this young team compete has reminded me of something.
I don’t watch hockey because I want to win the draft lottery.
I watch because I love the game.
I watch because there’s nothing quite like a goalie standing on his head, an underdog beating a favourite, or a young player celebrating like he’s just won the Stanley Cup after scoring his first NHL goal.
I watch because in 2004, a team that wasn’t supposed to be there gave us a spring we’ll never forget.
Miikka Kiprusoff came out of nowhere. Jarome Iginla led a team that refused to quit. And Martin “The Eliminator” Gelinas scored the series-winning goal in three consecutive rounds and what should have been the Stanley Cup-winning goal.
It was in!
Maybe that was lightning in a bottle.
Maybe we’ll never see another Kiprusoff arrive out of nowhere and turn everything upside down.
But who’s to say we can’t?
So let the kids play. Let them learn. Let them compete.
Because when it comes down to choosing between watching a team that’s genuinely having fun playing hockey and spending years hoping for the next generational superstar?
I vote for entertainment.
We’ve caught lightning in a bottle before.
Maybe next time we won’t have an official standing between us and the Stanley Cup.
And yes, Kerry Fraser wasn’t working Game 6. I’m blaming him anyway. Some traditions matter.
GO FLAMES GO!

